One of the top-selling pencils at both Ulta and Sephora, this ultra-precise pencil from Click for more information Benefit is best for faking natural-looking hairs. Use it on areas where you're sparse, then soften the lines with the attached spoolie. The best part? This tiny pencil is sturdy, so you don't have to worry about it breaking off. Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape Fill Eyebrow Pencil - Shade - Deep (Warm Black-Brown) This is more than just a brow pencil—it's basically a transformer. On one end is a spoolie, and on the other is a brow marker that's ideal to sketch in a few flicks of "hair." And under the spoolie? A third product: an angled pencil, which is ideal for elongating shorter brows. I like the look of the brow pencil part because I like a thicker point but I agree that the powder looks way too messy for my liking!